When I was about 2 or 3, I used to think Buddy Holly's Peggy Sue actually said "Eggy Soup" XP
A childhood belief about misheard lyrics

others believed things like this
- When I was little I thought that Buddy Holly was called Bloody Holly!— Catherine
- I used to think Buddy Rich was called Buddy Rich because he was my dad's friend, same with Buddy Holly. Anon
- I hated french onion soup so my dad told me that it was banana soup and i lapped it up for years.— AussieMeg
- Oldies Song Peggy Sue. I used to think that he was talking about how much he loves his "Baggy Suit".— Randy
- i thought that if i dressed in my holly hobby doll's clothes, no one would be able to find me.— pikl
- My buddy used to think that when Steve Millers sang "Jungle Love" he was actually saying "Chug-a-lug" — Harold