A very long time ago when Saturday Night Live was in its infancy, and I was just out of mine, Billy Joel did a guest spot. I can still remember him sitting at the piano, playing and singing -- and how proud I was that my Uncle Billy was on tv! At least until my mother pointed out that not every male with a beard named Billy was my Uncle Billy (to be fair, they did actually look somewhat alike). For years afterwards I still thought there was a chance that my Uncle Billy had a piano hidden somewhere in his house, and that everybody was lying to me because they were afraid I'd tell all my friends, and then they'd all want autographs.
A childhood belief about pop stars

others believed things like this
- My Uncle Billy used to tell us that if we swallowed chewing gum it would clog our bums up !
— Coolbuzz - I used to think that Sylvester Stallone and Billy Joel were the same person.Anon
- I used to think Billy Idols "Eyes without a face" was "How's about a date" : - )— Shay
- In old west lore, Billy the Kid was called 'buck toothed'. I thought this was because he sucked his thumb. — Monty
- Billy Squire sang about "My Kind of Lover". My wife sang about "My Candelabra"— Wailerman
- i thaught the michael jackson song billy jean song said Janet's not my son Anon