When I was a little kid I was convinced that Little Richard and Captain Hook were the same person. They both had the same hair, mustache and clothes. But I could never figure out how Little Richard could play piano so well with a hook for a hand.
A childhood belief about pop stars

others believed things like this
- That captain hook lived in my closet on the very top shelf.Anon
- I used to think "from which it stands" was "for Richard Stans".
— cobra - I always thought that Little Richard was Cliff Richards younger brother— adam
- Until recently, my friend believed that Richard Starkey was the fifth Beatle.— Spook
- I thought the Virgin Islands were owned by Richard Branson until I was 24. — LJ
- I used to think a mustache was just extended nose hair.— Dan