I thought that every singer was only entitled to one song. If you ended up with "Volare" or "Ode to Billy Joe", that was it; every new song written had to have a new singer to sing it. (I also thought it was "Ode to Billy Joel". I thought Billy Joel had found an interesting loophole to the one song/one singer rule by becoming a song subject.)
A childhood belief about pop stars

others believed things like this
- i thaught the michael jackson song billy jean song said Janet's not my son Anon
- I used to think that Sylvester Stallone and Billy Joel were the same person.Anon
- I thought that singer/songwriter was spelled this way: sing-a-song-writer...Anon
- In old west lore, Billy the Kid was called 'buck toothed'. I thought this was because he sucked his thumb. — Monty
- When I first heard Bruce Springsteen's song, "Born in the USA," I thought that the song was "Porn in the USA"Anon
- I thought that Whoopi Goldberg was a singer until I was about 10Anon