When they sang "When the roll is called up yonder" I always envisioned a piece of bread. It never occurred to me to wonder why a piece of bread would be called to heaven. I just took it on faith.
A childhood belief about hymns

others believed things like this
- I thought that the star that Mary and Joseph followed was called Yonder, as in 'following Yonder star."— Kairow
- i used to believe that one piece of ear wax was actually called a wach. — rachael
- Since we receive bread at Mass, I thought he was called "Jesus Crust" Seemed pretty obvious!Anon
- "Better than sliced bread"
I used to believe 'Sliced Bread' was a musical band.— Madeline - I used to believe that birds subsisted on bread.— C.C.
- If you ate the bread crust you would be able to whistle.Anon